Care Centers Should Provide Culturally Specific Treatment For Immigrants Social Work Essay

Topic: CultureTradition
Sample donated:
Last updated: July 11, 2020

The focal point of my research is based on obstructions experienced by immigrant seniors in accessing wellness attention in Canada. Immigrants come for all over the universe and can be white or racialized.

Because aging is a procedure that can non be prevented or avoided, I realize the demand to interrogate the deductions granted immigrant seniors are different in many ways and experience alone challenges. On reaching in Canada, immigrant seniors get enmeshed in the ineluctable multicultural rhythm. This entails hard procedures of integrating, assimilation and socialization.Bing in-between aged and a minority immigrant who experienced the overpowering impact of migration and the refugee procedure on my mental well-being, analyzing the barriers faced by immigrant seniors in accessing wellness attention is personal and political. On reaching, I got a sudden gradual realisation of difference frequently referred to as “ civilization daze ” . The devastation of clinical depression and post-traumatic emphasis upset was my lone invariable for three old ages. I consider myself literate but the Psychiatrist challenged my apprehension of this mental wellness phenomenon.

Don't use plagiarized sources.
Get Your Custom Essay on "Care Centers Should Provide Culturally Specific Treatment For Immigrants Social Work Essay..."
For You For Only $13.90/page!

Get custom paper

In my civilization depression or post-traumatic emphasis does non be. One is supposed to suck it up! While I argue that migration does dispute personal individuality and a sense of who we are, cultural difference impacts mental wellbeing. However, I do admit that mental wellness experiences of immigrants and refugees are personal and can be different within the same civilization. Despite claims multiculturalism makes race impersonal, proviso of mental wellness attention to immigrant seniors demonstrate that race and ethnicity remains a cardinal variable in Canada which influences people ‘s experiences and wellness results.The one thing shared in common by immigrants is a different civilization from the host state. Culture is concerned with beliefs and values on the footing of which people interpret experiences or specify unwellness. Leininger ( 1991 ) defines civilization asA ” the learned, shared and transmitted values, beliefs, norms and life ways of peculiar group that guides their thought, determinations and actions in patterned ways ” .

Culture provides an person with a manner of sing the universe as a beginning for interacting with others. Therefore, effectual primary wellness attention requires an apprehension of cultural influences that inform understanding of wellness or mental unwellness.While the diverseness has enriched economic growing, mental wellness becomes fundamental to overall mental wellbeing and productiveness. It is the footing for positive parts to household, community and society in general. With the dramatic addition of immigrant population growing a clear and effectual response to mental wellness and general wellbeing constitutes a major displacement and critical constituent confronting Canada ‘s wellness attention system. Despite claims multiculturalism makes race impersonal, proviso of mental wellness attention to immigrant seniors demonstrate that race and ethnicity remains a cardinal variable in Canada which influences people ‘s experiences and wellness results.

Proposed Research Rationale

In recent old ages, policy shapers and the medical experts have identified turning spreads in the proviso of mental wellness services to react to current demographic alterations as a consequence of in-migration in Canada.

The form of an addition in a racially, culturally and ethnically diverse population requires systemic alteration in order to run into non merely wellness but mental wellness demands. While most agree that mental unwellness affects all races, ethnicity and socioeconomic categories there is no consensus about how to react to the job of aging in culturally diverse society. Aged immigrants occupy multiple individualities which places them in a vulnerable place with both household members, public including wellness attention service suppliers.

Description of the Scope and Severity of the job

Immigrants represent a considerable big group of seniors.

Two tierces of seniors in Toronto are immigrants with adult females stand foring a big proportion Statistics Canada ( 2005 ) . Health Canada ( 2002 ) studies that 18 % of immigrants were aged 65 or older in comparing to 11 % of Canadian born. Lai ( 2000 ) listed depression as one of the most common mental wellness jobs impacting 10 % of the general aged population in Canada. However, no comparable informations exists on depression of racialized immigrant seniors. Because Canada ‘s population growing is based on in-migration, the ripening of immigrants present different outlooks than non-immigrants for wellness and mental wellness services.

The history of Canadian in-migration implies that most seniors were non born in Canada and have spent most of their lives in their place state. Therefore, the grade of assimilation and deficiency of resources creates a dependance on their kids. Even though research is available sing mental wellness of the larger population in general, research on mental wellness of senior immigrants in peculiar is fragmented. A few surveies have been conducted on Chinese, South Asian and Korean aged immigrants ( Lai & A ; Chau, 2007 ; Yoon, 2008 ) .

The Ontario Mental Health Statistical Sourcebook ( 1990 ) , states that one in every five grownup Canada will endure a mental upset in their life-time. The per centum sum is 21.3 per centum interpreting into 4.5 million people. Approximately 2.5 million grownups 18 and older will hold a depressive upset ( Ontario Mental Health Statistical Sourcebook, 1999 ) . Although these are generalized statistics the impact of migration and aging on mental wellness present alone challenges to healthcare proviso.

Research demonstrates economic load as one of the important load posed by mental wellness. In a comprehensive survey on deductions of economic impact of mental wellness in Canada research workers concluded that the load had well increased from $ 8.4 billion in 1998 to $ 51billion in 2003 ( Lim et al, 2008 ) . These amazing figures strongly suggest the importance of puting in advancing mental wellness non merely to Canadians but immigrants and refugees every bit good. Promotion of culturally specific mental wellness services would function as an investing because bar is cheaper than bring arounding. Besides, bar would cut down the astonishing economic load already stretched by Canadians accessing mental wellness services

A Review of the Literature

Language and Access to Health Care

Harmonizing to Statistics Canada 1 in 6 people in Canada are foreign born.

Canada accepts about 230, 000 immigrants per twelvemonth peculiarly from non-speaking English states. Datas from the Citizenship and Immigration Canada Research uncover an estimated 1in 50 of this population needs reading for wellness attention services ( CIC Research and Statistics, 2001 ) . Arguably, linguistic communication barrier poses a immense economic load but of significance is the chance that publicity of wellness and mental wellness attention does non make the immigrant and refugee population.

Green and Green ( 2004 ) argue that laterality of English linguistic communication in Canada led to exclusionary steps such as assimilation of fledglings through linguistic communication. Hence, for the most portion, linguistic communication was identified as a major obstruction faced by immigrant seniors. Since some of the immigrant seniors merely speak their cultural linguistic communications ; a deficiency of official linguistic communication accomplishments becomes a barrier to accessing necessary wellness attention services. Durst ( 2005 ) emphasizes the demand for different policies for sponsored immigrant seniors because the challenges they face are alone because they aged in their state of beginning.Neugebauer-Visano ( 1995 ) made similar observations about restrictions caused by linguistic communication restrictions and cultural differences. Immigrant seniors are forced to utilize household members to entree services. Depending wholly on their patrons makes them susceptible to mistreat and development. For illustration, immigrant seniors may be restricted to remaining in the place and babe sit while the grownup kids go to work.

Harmonizing to the Public Health Agency of Canada ( 2005 ) , for the most portion, immigrant seniors experience linguistic communication and cultural barriers that make them susceptible to isolation, development, and maltreatment.Harmonizing to Bowen ( 2001 ) , understanding official linguistic communications is the key to acquiring wellness attention information. Sponsored immigrant seniors are adversely affected by their deficiency of linguistic communication. The study states that it is hard for these seniors to take ESL categories as the ability to talk a 2nd linguistic communication can be lost with age.

Seniors are non able to show or depict their symptoms when they visit the infirmary or physician. To do the state of affairs worse, wellness attention suppliers lack cultural sensitiveness. It is reported that when a physician explains something, seniors may feign to understand merely because they may be tired of seeking elucidation all the clip. In fact, sponsored immigrant seniors prefer to confer with with service suppliers who can talk their native linguistic communication ( Koehn, 2006 ; Statistics Canada, 2005 ) . The figure of suppliers able to run into linguistic communication specific needs is either unavailable or limited, peculiarly in Toronto.

Barriers to Health and Mental Health Access

The National Advisory Council on Aging ( 2005 ) studies that despite the turning population of cultural minority seniors, research around wellness attention entree is still limited. At a symposium on entree to wellness attention for cultural minority seniors held in BC in April 2007, issues around entree to wellness attention were highlight of the event.

The study highlights barriers faced by sponsored racialized immigrant seniors, which include linguistic communication, deficiency of entree to information, and wellness attention.Lai and Chau ( 2007 ) observed that deficiency of cognition about bing health care services was interpreted as a barrier by the survey participants. In add-on, it was noted that cultural mutual exclusiveness and socialisation may forestall aged immigrants from accessing mental wellness attention. For case, mental wellness in other civilizations could be regarded as a black experience ( cited Choi and Gonzalez, 2005, Lai and Chau, 2007 ) . Therefore, the stigma and rejection associated with mental unwellness consequences in turning away and denial perpetuating wellness attention disparities that already be.

Additionally, old negative experiences with the wellness attention system facilitate support of misgiving of the wellness attention system.Sadavoy et Al ( 2004 ) identified cardinal barriers to include deficiency of linguistically and culturally appropriate mental wellness attention. Mental wellness workers were noted to miss sensitiveness and apprehension of culturally appropriate responses to mental unwellness. The survey participants pointed out the deficiency of privateness Psychiatrists were reported to take a firm stand immigrant seniors attend assignments with their ain translators. Granted household members and friends frequently provide reading immigrant seniors echoed this as a job because at times they are non comfy to uncover certain information to household members.Writers suggest adept demands assessment and plan design that can reconstruct the self-respect of immigrant seniors thereby bettering wellness and mental wellness. The writers experience is based on qualitative research surveies conducted to find better wellness attention supports for immigrant seniors.

Current apprehension of the Issue

A figure of surveies indicate that new immigrant seniors suffer from a high figure of mental wellness jobs. Sadavoy et Al ( 2004 ) argue that immigrant seniors identify symptoms of depression, emphasis, and religious crisis that are related to in-migration. This is attributed to the fact that depression may be non-existent in their place state. Another job highlighted by assorted researches was the stigma associated with mental unwellness. Cultural perceptual experience of mental unwellness is reported as a cause for hold in seeking intervention for aged seniors.The passage in acceptance of Canadian civilization and linguistic communication adversely affects immigrant seniors. Literature available indicates that linguistic communication barriers are a major job experienced by immigrant seniors.

Seniors who are sponsored by their grownup kids or grandchildren are non eligible for societal services for 10 old ages. Because of this, they become isolated in civilization and linguistic communication since the lone interaction would be the household members. Existing literature suggests continued systematic exclusion of senior immigrants ‘ from full engagement in economic, cultural and societal activities ( Neugebauer-Visano, 1995 ; Durst, 1005 ) . At the same clip, entree to wellness and mental wellness attention varies across different groups and services. For illustration, Sadavoy et Al ( 2004 ) observed that community based bureaus using ethno specific workers were perceived to be most accessible and welcoming to immigrant seniors.

What does research neglect to turn to?

While research has contributed vastly towards understanding of different mental wellness conditions in some immigrant communities, more demands to be done to research the barrier posed by a wellness attention system that reflects the perceptual experiences, values and precedences of a dominant civilization.

Then once more, research fails to admit the strength of immigrants and refugees who come from corporate communities. Community development could be explored to construct sustainable communities that can act upon power constructions to take barriers that prevent engagement. Research has failed to leverage community centred attacks to turn to wellness and mental wellness attention for immigrant seniors ; an attack that could be successfully implemented.

Despite the continued addition in the immigrant senior population, research has non yet developed schemes to turn to the linguistic communication and communicating barrier. This would be a two thronged attack necessitating both client and service supplier developing transverse cultural apprehension of each other. Research can bridge the spread echoed in several literature that immigrant seniors lack the cognition about mental wellness resources. Bridging the spread between handiness and handiness of services would chase away the impression that handiness means handiness. Immigrant seniors have echoed deficiency of linguistic communication accomplishments and mobility issues. Thus, farther research is needed to develop targeted plans for the diverse immigrant and refugee senior population.Sing the continued addition in the Numberss of senior immigrants in Canada, it is imperative that farther research is conducted to bridge the spread of handiness and handiness of wellness and mental wellness services. For illustration, the deficiency of cognition about available resources raised in several research could be addressed by supplying linguistically appropriate literature.

Furthermore, to turn to the issue of linguistic communication, ESL categories frequently offered upon reaching to Canada could be structured for a ulterior clip when the immigrant seniors have settled. Adapting to the inauspicious conditions and different civilization impacts mental well-being such that concentration at that clip is limited.Some immigrant seniors come to Canada traumatized by war or nerve-racking life events. Research fails to separate particular considerations that this peculiar group of immigrants and refugee require in order to incorporate successfully into the host state. For illustration, Vucetic ( 2001 ) recommends proviso of ESL categories catered for seniors. Useful subjects on wellness and aging in Canada could be included in the course of study. Therefore, peer battle could advance airing of information while developing societal interaction while larning English.

Because civilization plays an built-in function in version, research fails to look into misinterpretations that arise between senior immigrants and wellness attention suppliers.The position supported by statistics that 16 % of immigrants live with household members as opposed to 6 % of Canadians is misdirecting ( Liu and Kerr, 2003 ) . This information fails to admit the fluctuations in immigrant communities in regard of caring for their aged members. Policy planning that makes these premises are misdirecting and farther the disparities noted in the Surgeon General Report ( 2001 ) .


In the concluding analysis, what becomes clear is that civilization and societal context drama a important function in determining the mental wellness of immigrant seniors. Cultural misinterpretations act upon the type of mental wellness service used or provided.

Multicultural used to depict Canada ‘s platform of equity and inclusion falls short in footings of mental wellness of immigrant seniors. Based on the literature under reappraisal, the Multiculturalism Act has non been sensitive to reflect the alone wellness attention demands presented by immigrant seniors. Durst ( 2005 ) argues despite the involvement in ethnicity and aging demonstrated by research workers, impact of the two intersecting variables have been given consideration. A public policy study called, “ A Profile of Canada ‘s Older Population ” neglected to include ethnicity as a capable affair ( Durst, 2005 ) .

The experiences and wellness results of immigrant seniors are determined by race and ethnicity. There is considerable research on Asiatic immigrant seniors for illustration, Lai, 2000 ; Mackinnon et Al, 2001. Lack of comparative research between immigrants and non-immigrants demonstratesResearch on the deductions of policies and plans for aging minority seniors is required to guarantee cultural relevancy ( Durst, 1996 ) . Similarly, Lai ( 2003 ) and Kobayashi ( 2003 ) stress the demand for development of equal policies that cut down multiple troubles that prevent cultural minority immigrant seniors from accessing formal support webs. This point is reiterated by legion research surveies that illustrate how native born citizens are used as a mention point to modulate the behavior of foreign born immigrants.

Choose your subject


I'm Jessica!

Don't know how to start your paper? Worry no more! Get professional writing assistance from me.

Click here